There are a number of wonderfully caring and perfectly respectable dog rescue organizations out there, but unfortunately not all of them are what they seem. The newest scam is for supposed rescuers to search shelters, Craigslist, The Penny Saver, etc., to locate dogs which are in high demand and easy to sell. These con-artists will then obtain the dog, often seeking out purebred or family dogs, and then sell them. They will refer to this charge as an adoption or rehoming fee, and will turn around and make a pretty serious profit.

Guapo and Flicka, Both Rescued from San Diego SheltersThe scammers will tell you that included in your re-homing fee is spay/neuter and shots, while in reality the animals had received these services from where ever the alleged ‘rescuer’ got the dog. They may even go on to tell you that they have to recover the costs of rescuing the dog and caring for the dog, but if this trully is the case, then they should be considered a dog kennel, in which case strict rules and regulations would apply that they most likely do not meet. Some of these people actually con the shelters into waving or reducing fees, taking money away from the shelter and putting it right into their own pocket.

Shelter fees are usually between $60-$100 for a dog, and this is usually the case across the board. No special exceptions are made for purebred dogs or dogs with a high likelihood of being adopted out; the rescue is looking out for the best interest of the animals, and wants to make it financially possible for these dogs to find their forever homes. So, in a nutshell, these people, under the guise of being a friend to animals, make a $200-$400 profit for each dog they obtain from the shelter or other adoption means – CL, local classifieds, etc. Do that a couple times a week and you can give up your day job!

Be careful of these people posing as rescuers when checking out an adoptable dog outside of a well-known animal shelter. Ask detailed questions, ask about their non-profit status, ask details about the animal – it’s origin, temperament, how long it has been with them, and be sure to visit the dog in person before agreeing to any money being exchanged. Be aware that non profits are not allowed to charge fees, but they may ask for voluntary donations. Ask for a discount, if the person is in it for the money you can often tell by the tone of their voice when you ask for a discount. If they reply with, “I have laid out so money to save the dog and want to recover my expenses” ask for receipts and proof before continuing with the adoption.

Keira, Owner: BrianThere is another class of rescuers/rescue organizations who are equally harmful to animals, they are the ones who ask invasive questions or demand inappropriate access to your life in order to adopt the animal. There is a fine line between inspecting someone’s home to be sure that the dog will be placed in a safe environment and asking for 10 letters of recommendation, a contract signed with blood, and the threat that they can take your dog back at any time. A well-publicized case of this sort of incident is what happened to Ellen Degeneres’ rescued dog. If you pay for a dog it’s yours, irregardless of what they say or make you sign. Target can’t come take back that TV you bought last year if they don’t approve of the adult channels you subscribe to, and the simple truth is, that same principal applies to dogs. Target also has no say about that TV if you decide to give it away later on.

I have heard of flipping houses, but flipping dogs? It is just inhumane any way you look at it. I think selling dogs should be prohibited, even if it’s called rehoming fee or not, it all just comes down to semantics in the end; this practice needs to be banned. There are thousands of dogs who need homes and charging for dogs just makes it all the worse, actually preventing many animals from being placed with loving owners.

Now that you are aware – do not make it easy for them. Any fee should be suspect, especially when it is in excess of $75. If something does not seem right, take action – turn them in, call a legitimate animal protection agency for advice, but please take steps to help stop these predators.


COMMENTS / 17 COMMENTS

Thank you for this article. I know of a retired racing greyhound scam that is actually funneling dogs for a person who breeds indiscriminately and keeps the dogs in deplorable conditions. These dogs have never seen a racetrack and they are breeding these dogs for hunting live prey. What can I do to report this nonprofit scam? They charge a few hundred for adoption fees and they are cloaked in respectability but in reality they are supporting uncontrolled breeding and the place where the dogs are kept is disease infested and overcrowded. How can this be stopped?

crazy4hounds added these pithy words on Jun 12 08 at 1:23 pm

I don’t know where you live, but nobody in the Northeast can adopt out a dog for “$75-$100. Cats go for that from rescues up here, dogs for much more, especially if they’re puppies and the neutering, vaccinations, etc. are included, which they usually are. While it’s true that lots of scammers are out there, it is completely unfair to make most of the statements you make in this article. And whetner or not they can legally make you honor your promise, a promise is a promise and Ellen broke hers. She had no right to do that and should probably not have gotten the dog in the first place. One of the many advantages of adopting from a rescue instead of craigslist or the like is that the rescues will take the animal back if it doesn’t fit into the particular adoption situation while craigslist animals are often problem animals being dumped and the former owners don’t answer their phone when the new owners try to contact them to return the animal that wasn’t as advertised. I do agree that selling dogs — and cats — should be illegal but if everyone in the Northeast follows your uninformed advice, the no-kill shelters here will all close and nobody will be able to find any rescued pets; they’ll all be euthanized in the kill shelters. Please do some research before making such suggestions.

JK added these pithy words on Aug 31 08 at 1:29 am

I live in the Northeast and the shelters absolutely DO adopt puppies and dogs out within your mentioned price range ($60-$100). It is the unregulated “rescues” that won’t adopt out for less than $300. Cats are even less at a shelter. In fact, look for yourself at Petfinder.com and find Adirondak Save A Stray in Corinth, NY. They are having a “two for the price of one” special on kittens right now to try and make way for some new cats who need a place to stay until adoption. Sounds like your article was well researched, and it brings to light a deplorable part of the “animal lover” community that is for some reason treated as acceptable pratice. Bravo on this article.

EB added these pithy words on Aug 31 08 at 7:06 pm

I am not sure what the issue is. So, somebody finds dogs for cheap and sells them for more? OK, so people do it with homes, cars, all manner of merchandise on ebay – why should dogs be different? If people are willing to shell out serious $$$ for a dog – it’s a supply and demand thing, really…

Tauro added these pithy words on Sep 01 08 at 10:16 pm

I got sucked into more than one scam when trying to find a dog. I’ve driven as far as 2+ hours on more than one occasion to meet a dog/pup. But, no big money, no dog! I was suspicious. Did an internet search on one person, found a very interesting article on her. Seems she gave a very sick dog to someone and it died the next day and then she practically forced another one on her the same day. She was and still is “flipping dogs”, getting them from shelters than charging high “adoption” fees! I was refused a dog even though I went through the whole process of filling out very lengthy forms, having references and vets called. But, they didn’t tell me about the big money until after I met the dog and adored it. They were pushy to make up my mind by the next morning and at least leave $150 to hold the dog. I NEVER heard from them again! They found someone who would give them the $250-$300. My advice, Be careful when they are pushy, even the so called foster family. I may be wrong, but maybe they are making some $$ too or are suckered into the scam. My experience was identical to what wa written in the article here!!! I did get my new pup! The owner didn’t ask for one dollar!! She just wanted a new loving home. I drove 2 hours to go pick up my baby. Gave the owner $100 to cover all of the accessories that she gave me. Now that’s a REAL adoption! And, all other folks that I contacted who had dogs up for adoption, I would write to them saying, if you’re a Foster family or if you’re going to ask for a hefty “fee”, don’t reply to me. The ONLY one who did reply out of about 20 – 25 folks, was the one that I got my pup from. You can’t convince me otherwise that alot of these adoptions are not making more money than they put out for these dogs! I’ve been there! And I’ve gone as far as Cobleskill, NY where the shelter required less than $75 for a dog with all shots and dog license. So, JK, YOU should do some research! The info in the article was exactly what I experienced! And I wasn’t the only one!

Marg added these pithy words on Nov 09 08 at 11:14 am

PET RESCUE OR RESALE?????

I WAS trying to adopt a small mixed breed dog(not too picky about color etc..) from a “pet rescue”. The lady sent me a picture of a mixed Shih TZu (spelled shitzu! LOL!) I asked this lady THREE times how much for a small breed young dog/puppy. She hee-hawed around saying finally,”It depends on the vet bills”. WTF???? A puppy wellness check costs 100 bucks for most folks even at the best clinics. I know most Vets will cut rescue groups a break. Throw in food,time,paperwork and some grooming and you’re looking at MAYBE 300.00 bucks. If the dog has extensive medical problems I don’t want a sick dog! I’m paying enough for the aging issues with the dogs I have. I will eventually have to pay for elderly care for any dog I adopt. I want to start off healthy!
I’ve looked at other “rescues” as a guideline for the adoption prices. The normal price range is 400-600 dollars for any small,young and healthy dog. WHY so much? You can get a purebred AKC dog for that much. I don’t plan to breed,show or brag on this dog. It’s a pet just like my 2 other mutt dogs.
I won’t be getting a dog from “rescue” half of those “animal people” are insane IMHO anyway. A great deal of the “rescue people” are really animal hoarders.
I’ll either find what I want at the local shelter or buy a dog. I now call them “pet resales” instead of pet rescue. They are taking in quite a profit. Did anyone know they CHARGE to take a dog in THEN charge AGAIN to adopt out? One guy paid them 300 bucks to TAKE his dog and RESELL IT.
The contracts are bizarre. If I BUY an animal from someone and they don’t like the way it’s being raised(within the law) I’ll probably kick thier butt (shoot them,turn the big dogs on them etc…)if they’d try to kidnap MY dog back (To resell it again I suspect). So it’s better if I just buy a puppy or try to get lucky at the shelter. I’ve seen rescues CLEAN OUT a public shelter of it’s small,adoptible dogs so that might get tricky finding one for myself. Wish me luck! PJ

Paula Treadwell added these pithy words on Jan 08 09 at 2:37 pm

This article is absolutely true. I live in NYC. Fell in-love with a boxer mix at the kill shelter only to have it adopted out from under me by a foster group who would then adopt it to me for $300. Yes, the vet care was free and the cost of adoption for the foster group, as the dog was over 5yrs, was $25. The foster group is run on-site and picks out close to purebred dogs to ‘foster’. A foster home is a free place for the dog until they find a buyer. Any additional vet bills are usually donated as a write-off. The forms and questions asked are as extreme as described in the article. I’ve been trying to adopt a dog for months. The last one, a chow chow being fostered. I was denied because I live in a 650 sq. ft. loft. They said this dog needs a backyard. Any light breed research on chow chows will agree they are perfect for apartments, low energy indoors, needing a long walk a day. These foster groups are bias towards apartment dwellers, who are more likely to go for long walks and give proper exercise than the home owner who opens up the door to the yard. What the shelters are left with are pitbulls. A fine breed but not for everyone.

MJ added these pithy words on Oct 04 09 at 2:59 pm

Deal with a rescue that is a 501c3. Ask alot of questions!! Dog should have ALL shots including Boratello, de-worming and heartworm test. If the rescue gives out a dog that is not spayed or neutered, then they should have a spay/neuter contract and then rescue follows up on it. All dogs should be spayed and neutered. Adopter should recieve all paperwork showing dog is vetted…proper paperwork with a vet name and # to call and verify. Ask how long the dog has been in rescue, who has had it, where did it come from. Ask alot of questions and deal with honest rescue groups that are a 501c3!

jan sebald added these pithy words on Oct 15 09 at 2:27 pm

This article disgusts me. Who are you and how dare you! Good rescues don’t make any money at all. They take the really sick and injured dogs, rehabiliate them and yes, charge a fairly high adoption fee which is completely tax deductible, which I see you failed to mention. Even though the dog the rescue has may not have needed $400 worth of care, the next dog that comes in may have needed $1000 worth of care because of the abuse and neglect they suffered at the hands of humans. There are bad rescues out there, it’s up to you to do your homework before you adopt.Yes they check your home adn your references. If you don’t like it, too bad, go to the shelter. Nodboy forced you to go the route of rescue. Shelters are funded at a state and federal level, most rescues are private.

Steph added these pithy words on Jan 14 10 at 12:46 pm

Steph,

First, to answer your questions:

Who are you? I am a pit bull advocate, rescuer, and volunteer with my local rescue in San Diego. I will be happy to answer any other questions you may have about my personal life via email.

How dare you? I created this website to help inform people about the pit bull breed and other dog-related issues. As an active volunteer with a rescue organization, many issues surrounding animal adoption are brought to my attention on a regular basis. I wrote this article as a warning to people to be careful who they are adopting from, because I have seen first hand the dishonesty described in the article.

I think you are missing the point the article is trying to convey, which is that people need to exercise caution when adopting a dog from a “rescue”. Unfortunately, not all rescue organizations are what they seem. With regard to adoptions being tax deductible, you are absolutely right; IF you adopt from a rescue with 501c3 status. The underground rescue scams I am referring to in the article are not these types of organizations. They are instead people/groups that are obtaining pure bred, high demand dogs from shelters, only to turn around and re-sell them at a profit to unsuspecting people who adopt the dogs thinking they are getting them from a reputable rescue organization.

I am glad to see that you care enough about animal welfare to get angry about this subject, but I do feel you are perhaps a bit misguided in your efforts. Keep in mind, the point of a “good rescue” is not to turn a profit, but to save animals.

admin added these pithy words on Jan 14 10 at 4:49 pm

Posting an article like this is VERY misleading. It generalizes and only explains one side of the story. I TOO am a rescuer. One person took your article and took it too the bank. She reported a rescue to the state and started publishing on public forums. Does the rescue have a bad rap, perhaps, but the point I am trying to make is that because this article is out there, she took it great lengths to publicly state that rescues that charge high adoption fees are only doing it to make money and I can assure you, good rescues struggle to make ends meet. If it’s in the best interest of the dog, I have even seen fees waived if someone is willing to take on the responsibility of a troubled dog. There are BAD rescues, there is a bad version of everything. It’s up to people to do their homework. Sometimes you have to have a profit, if you don’t you can’t take the next one in that needs $4000 worth of surgery. I am not misguided at all. I am actually very well educated.

Steph added these pithy words on Jan 15 10 at 8:20 am

I find most of these dog rescue groups are run by militant frigid crazy ladies that want to control your life and rip you off.

You would HAVE TO BE TOTALLY NUTS to deal with ANY of these dog rescue groups! Basically, if you sign ANY agreement, you are leasing a dog from them, not adopting. If they can take the dog away, than YOU don’t own it. If you buy a dog from a breeder you don’t have to sign ANY agreement or wavers like these groups want you to.

After reading about all the hoops I would have to jump through, I will buy a puppy from a breeder or get one from the pound.

cc added these pithy words on Feb 13 10 at 6:32 pm

Wow.
Thanks for this article. I have been looking on-line to try to find a dog and have inquired after several only to be wrung through the inquisition in one, left hanging on others, and phoned two only to see that the dog listed “was adopted today…bet we have others”.

I was beginning to wonder about some things. My only pets have come from either my vets office or from the animal shelter where I just went in to pick one out.

I have decided to only look at places like ‘shelter’, ‘humane society’,or ‘animal control’ in their listings – or ‘free to good home’. Hopefully I’ll find what I’m looking for!

Cathy S. added these pithy words on Mar 03 10 at 2:51 pm

I HAVE BEEN lOOKING TO ADOPT A SMALL DOG AS WELL AND HAVE ENCOUNTERED WHAT I BELIEVE TO BE SCAMS ON KIJIJI.COM… NOT EXACTLY SURE THEY ARE ON THE UP AND UP. I TOO HAVE BECOME LEARY OF ADS FOUND ON PETFINDER.COM AND THEIR ANIMAL “RESCUERS”. I AM GLAD I SAW THIS WEBSITE SINCE IT SEEMS MY SUSPICIONS WERE LIKELY TRUE- SOMETHING IS NOT RIGHT ABOUT ALL THIS. I MAY STICK WITH NSAL , WHICH I HAVE BEEN VERY LUCKY WITH TWICE ALREADY IN THE PAST OR ASPCA. THANKS

Noreen added these pithy words on Mar 13 10 at 2:44 pm

adoption groups is just another form of puppy mill supporter, not that all puppy mills are bad, most of them are regulated by a.k.c. and are better than most child care facilities. i have been in the pet industry for years and years and i have never met one adoption group tha was legit. everyone of them charged between $350.00 and $500.00 for a dog and i have seen everyone of them at dog auctions. dog auctions are held for pet store owners, in which these puppies come from mills. or private breeders. you would not believe how many people are there from adoption groups, bidding and buying puppies for at the max… $50.00 then take them back to pet stores on the weekends and try to adopt them out for 350 to 500. it’s all a scam and people fall for it all the time. get real people. research this get the facts, it’s true

cindy added these pithy words on Apr 26 10 at 12:36 pm

Thank you! I thought I was just overly sensitive. I had been looking for a sweet, mellow companion dog and found the same high adoption fees and invasive questions that everyone here has been complaining about. $450 in “adoption fees” and a very creepy contract saying that the dog can be repossessed at any time PLUS some very rude and weird questions from the foster mom. I ended up going to the ASPCA shelter and found a wonderful Lab mix. At first, I was feeling guilty about not “helping a local rescue group” but I am now having serious misgivings about the whole matter. It will be the ASPCA shelter for me from now on! The local rescue group where I live is supposed to focus on rescuing local homeless pets but they actually go two hours out of town to get chihuahuas from a shelter. The “flipping” dogs for profit theory makes total sense. Again, thanks for giving voice to my suspicions. I am glad I did not give these people one dime.

Blanche added these pithy words on Jul 05 10 at 11:47 pm

that is croak north shore animal leg in new york only charges 75 bucks for any dog ,as for the guy who ask what the problem is , its that i can buy a pup for 300.00 , but i wanted to save a dog but they said it would cost me 350.for a small dog!!!!!!!!!!!!

rodney added these pithy words on Jul 21 10 at 10:07 pm

SPEAK / ADD YOUR COMMENT
Comments are moderated.

XHTML: You can use these tags: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Return to Top

Dog Adoption Scams

LATEST POSTS / RECENT TOPICS